Reddit reviews BAGGU Women's Duck Bag, Black, One Size

Can anyone recommend a zip-top, medium to large sized tote bag with a cross body strap and minimal hardware/branding in the sub $150-200 range? Preferably in black and in a material that can handle light rain.

I recently ordered this bag in black for an upcoming trip. I really like how it looks, it's water resistant and well made, but it's simultaneously both huge on the outside and too small on the inside. Like a reverse Mary Poppins...

I really like the size and simplicity of this baggu tote, but I know I don't have the sewing skills to add a zipper in a good looking way before my trip. I also checked out the Madewell transport satchel but was pretty underwhelmed by the feel of the leather handles/strap for the price point. This Cuyana bag is really nice, but is at the top of my budget and maybe not very weather resistant. I'd prefer something I could evaluate in a brick and mortar store before purchasing.

Thanks!

I found this minimalist tote bag and I'm thinking of buying it. Is it too feminine?