Reddit reviews No More Pacifier, Duck (Hello Genius)

HI! First, sorry if this is long winded! We just got rid of the pacifier for our two year old over the Thanksgiving holiday. Like you, she was only a night time user. But, it was her security, and she always had to have 3 in her crib when she fell asleep (one in mouth, one in each hand). I was worried about going cold turkey for the same reason, especially cus' it was WWIII when her pacifiers fell out of the crib in the middle of the night! We went with the Paci Fairy idea. I also got a couple books which we read for about 2 weeks before D-day. Basically, we talked about how we had to give the pacifiers away to the Paci Fairy, and she would in turn give her a present. That night we gathered all the pacifiers, put it in an envelope and wrote a note to the fairy and left it outside the door. I gave her a new teddy bear to snuggle and in the morning she woke up and found her present outside. She did surprisingly well with it all; she didn't even cry when I left her room that night. There wasn't even a lot of crying in the night. We did get up maybe 4-5 times the first night to settle her, 2 times for the next two nights, and then shes been back to sleeping through the night ever since. The nap has definitely been harder than night time. I actually threw all the pacifiers away to not allow myself to give in if things were tough. I think the books were the most helpful. Especially this one, cus' the duck is alsoa bedtime exclusive user. I also go the Bea Gives Up Her Pacifier one, but I didn't like how they tell the toddler to think about food when you miss your pacifier... seemed to send a weird message. GOOD LUCK!