Reddit reviews Sculpey III Oven Bake Clay Sampler 1oz, 30/pkg

Seconded. Polymer clay could work well for this. That way you could cure it in the oven. Air-dry clay would work well for this too and may give you a more rugged appearance like they belong in-game.

• Paizo Flip Mats - link
  
• Kaplow Jumbo Dice sets - link
  
• Quality wood art box for storage - link
  
• Homemade miniatures using steel washers as a base and various sizes, crafts store clay with many colors to form on top, stamps for letters to make them distinct, and paint pen to fill in the letter for contrast.

I did buy it. Here's a link to the clay I like to use. But that's kind of a lot of clay if you've never tried it before. (Plus I had a lot of paint lying around.) If you buy something like this you can get a lot of colors, and it will work just as well. You can also get a similar package at Walmart for cheaper. You can bake it in the oven at home. I might recommend wearing some gloves if you can, because I've found that some of the colors come off on your hands, especially the red. I used acrylic paint to make the eyes, which you can buy at Walmart for like 50 cents/bottle. You could also use a sharpie if you want. Hope this helps!

If I had this... I could be ALMOST as cool as you.

I love the animals you make. Maybe you can make a rainbow maned unicorn... THAT would be sweet as hell. Like this SOOO damn cute.

Here's a dragon you could try...

That's turtley awesome!

When I was a kid I used to get Highlights magazine sent to my house every month. It was MARVELOUS! My favorite thing about it was the search and find. I would suggest these magazines for your daughters because that are fun and educational and everyone loves getting things in the mail. It's really awesome. I currently do it for my son who is 2. We are still getting the year 0-2 because they also send books. Which is great. My grandmother just signed us up on Christmas.

• Adela - Spirograph I remember these used to be so much fun. They were amazing. Make sure to get colored pencils, a pencil sharpener and lots of fun paper too for this present.
  
  
• Isla Sculpey clay. Since she likes play-doh, clay is a superior product and doesn't "spoil" so to speak. You can buy it on amazon. The best part about sculpey is that when you shape it to what you want, you can then bake it. Then it becomes a hard like figure which she can then paint. I feel like this would be a super fun project to do with both the girls. Get them set up on the table to roll and play with their clay. Get some of those molds for clay to help them create something and then have them bake it and paint it! Can keep them entertained for a few hours with a resulted finished product. You might be able to have a preplanned product to make before going into it. For instance, Try to make real simple animals. There are easy tutorials of balllike animals that are wicked cool. Type that into google watch the video. I would link it but I"m in class right now and this guy is just going on and on and I'd love to have a video interrupt my Ben Stein teacher but... I'd also like to pass the class so.. Sorry you'll just have to google that. Anyway, so
  
  For Isla I would suggest: Sculpey clay, molds and presses for the clay, and kid paints. This is great for gifts too.. have them make stuff for others. It helps improve dexterity skills which makes it a really great idea.
  
  Both of these gifts are interactive and are able to be used by both of the Princesses.
  
  EDIT:: Sculpey clay
  
  Sculpey with colors in it already
  
  Fun molds
  
  

What it looks like post bake

This is where you buy it