Reddit Reddit reviews Sociology is a Martial Art: Political Writings by Pierre Bourdieu

We found 1 Reddit comments about Sociology is a Martial Art: Political Writings by Pierre Bourdieu. Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.

Books
Philosophy
Social Philosophy
Politics & Social Sciences
Sociology is a Martial Art: Political Writings by Pierre Bourdieu
Used Book in Good Condition
Check price on Amazon

1 Reddit comment about Sociology is a Martial Art: Political Writings by Pierre Bourdieu:

u/Liara_cant_act ยท 3 pointsr/politics

Thanks for your kind words. I started having these thoughts back in my early college days when I was majoring in econ. I found it odd how the theories I was being taught were so simple and clear, yet there was so much political disagreement. I thought, "Why is there so much argument over what to do when the answers are so obvious!?"

Then I started actually reading history and realized that things were not nearly so simple. That economics as it was taught to me is simplified and censored to the point of having almost no relationship to the real world. I eventually stumbled upon political economist Karl Polanyi's classic The Great Transformation and his concept of fictitious commodities, and that broke the dam/blew my mind.

Once I got into science, I found it very telling how all the economists and business people I had met were much more confident in their theories of the world than the chemists and biologists I was working with, despite the fact that the latter had much more solid empirical ground to stand on. That's the effect of ideology, I guess; you don't question it or even realize it is there.

If you are interested in these topics, I would recommend:

the aforementioned Polanyi book

Debt: the First 5,000 Years by David Graeber

The Origins of Political Order by Francis Fukuyama

This long academic paper by law professors Jon Hanson & David Yosifon

And some essays by Pierre Bourdieu, such as Social Scientists, Economic Science and the Social Movement and Neoliberalism, the Utopia (Becoming a Reality) of Unlimited Exploitation, which can be found in Sociology is a Martial Art

A quick Google or wikipedia search will reveal these authors' backgrounds and any possible biases they may have in your view. It is fun to see a founder of neoconservatism (Fukuyama) and an anarchist anthropologist who helped start Occupy Wall Street (Graeber) essentially agree on the total historical inaccuracy of modern economic thought and the corrosive impact of economics on the other social sciences.