Reddit reviews The Unofficial Guide to the Disney Cruise Line 2016 (Unofficial Guide Disney Cruise Line)
We found 1 Reddit comments about The Unofficial Guide to the Disney Cruise Line 2016 (Unofficial Guide Disney Cruise Line). Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.
You might want to lurk on the DISBOARDS forums a bit (usually I try not to nudge people off reddit but DCL just doesn't get discussed much here):
http://www.disboards.com/forums/disney-cruise-line-forum.9/
That said, the first thought that comes to mind is ... DCL is probably a lot more expensive for the same itinerary than other lines (including other lines that will have childcare). If money isn't a factor, you can't beat Disney for a family cruise.
The Disney ships are EXTREMELY Disneyfied. That said, if it doesn't drive you crazy in the parks, you'll be fine on the ships. I've only been on the Dream, and I'm both childless and not a Disney nut. It got to me a bit, but it was offset by the cleanliness of the ship and the fabulous staff. We also got a room with a big balcony, and we spent a lot of time there or in the adults-only areas. There should be an adults-only area on Magic, and you could go there while the kid is at the nursery (or whatever they call it for that age range, sorry).
If you do book, in my opinion it's worth spending the extra ten or twelve bucks and grabbing this:
https://www.amazon.com/Unofficial-Guide-Disney-Cruise-Line/dp/1628090502/
Things change very quickly on ALL cruise lines, but the folks behind these books have a very good handle on Disney and DCL. I bought the electronic version and made lots of bookmarks on my kindle.
EDIT: Oh, and if possible you may want to book through Costco. They usually have a fairly large kickback in the form of a Costco cash card. It's basically the only way to save money on a DCL cruise.