(Part 2) Best shoes for women according to redditors
We found 4,996 Reddit comments discussing the best shoes for women. We ranked the 4,371 resulting products by number of redditors who mentioned them. Here are the products ranked 21-40. You can also go back to the previous section.
I think depending on the style of the loafer or oxford, it can be fine. I wouldn't cheap out and get something trendy or casual, which will not only look juvenile, but will show wear much easier. Some examples of what not to get: this, this, this
The last pic may seem fine, but I think it's lacking in terms of structure, so it comes off as pretty casual.
Some examples of what to look for: this, this, this, and this
FWIW, I've had better luck finding nice quality loafers than nice oxfords/wingtips. There are some UK brands which make some excellent wingtips for women, but since I don't know my size and it'd be an (expensive) international order for me, I just admire them from afar.
I would look for a basic heel from Clarks. They don't sell mine anymore but I found these that I would totally buy if I were looking: https://www.amazon.com/CLARKS-Womens-Quest-Sandal-Leather/dp/B07M9BFWMY/ref=sr_1_14?keywords=clarks+heels+women&qid=1558469726&s=gateway&sr=8-14
​
Block heels, simple straps, neutral colors are the way to go!
You guys, I’ve been the luckiest thrifter recently. Here’s a roundup of some - but not all - of the things I thrifted in the last 30 days or so:
This pair of Clarks for $6. They’re so cute (unlike your typical old lady Clarks) and comfortable and I loved them so much that I bought a second pair from eBay for $29. I want to wear them every day forever.
Two pairs of Rag & Bone skinny jeans - this one and this one. They were a little pricy for thrift at $14 and $16 each, but Rag & Bone skinnies have been on my wishlist for a while so this really helps a broke girl out. They still feel really stiff and sturdy, like they were never worn or broken in.
These J Brand Maria jeans with a cute ankle zip. The model picture of these makes me laugh because they’re much less cropped and a bit higher waisted on my short legs.
A Calvin Klein fuzzy camel coat ($11) like this. It’s alpaca and wool. Just in time for summer, ha, but it looks really great on so I couldn’t resist.
A Theory blouse that looks exactly like this one only it’s 95% silk and a pale mauve color ($6).
A Barbour L116 Black Microfibre Short Quilted Jacket like this one ($15). I’m tempted to flip it, but I’m a sucker for black basics so I can’t!
These & Other Stories leather loafers, but in black. I couldn’t find a picture of the black ones anywhere online to save my life.
These Calvin Klein black skinny pants ($7). They’re super comfortable!
These Bass black faux leather sneakers ($4).
This Diane Von Furstenberg tank ($3). It’s silk and viscose and has actual goldtone chains woven across the front.
Topshop mid blue Jamie jeans ($8). These have also been on my denim wishlist. They’re super stretchy but in great shape. Also grabbed a pair of Levi’s just like these and some black BDG skinnies like these for $4 each. Yay! I’ve been replacing all my denim recently because I went up a couple sizes and the thrift gods just keep blessing me.
I also randomly stumbled across these never-worn Eileen Fisher sandals for $8 shipped on Mercari so obviously I bought them! I wasn’t sure how I felt about them, but they’ve grown on me and I’m glad I grabbed them.
Those are the Nine West Speakup. I can't say they're the most comfortable flats I own but I like the overall look so I just throw in some insoles and deal haha
My pairs from Dr. Scholls and Corso Como are more comfortable out of the box
For people set on having camp shoes, I've started using water socks with a thin rubber sole. They are just enough to protect my feet while not letting small pebbles and sticks in. Something like this:
SIMARI Unisex Water Sports Shoes Barefoot Slip-on Indoor Outdoor Sports Activities SWS001 Stripe Black 9.5-10.5 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G2WY2SJ/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_vlfsDbN0SYDV2
I love these Sanuk Women's Yoga Sling 2 Flip Flop,Black,8 M US https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00DQYNWJ8/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_L6vyzbG6E7T4Y
Hunter boots. Everyone I talked to said, "Oh, they're so cute. . .but they leak sometimes. They're so great, though!" and I just thought it was ridiculous to buy rain boots that leak.
I bought these Kamik Jennifer boots instead and they're terrific. Low profile, solidly constructed, and super comfortable. I've walked miles in them at a time!
Okay so first off, be aware that really the only way to wear rain boots in winter in nothern states is with wool socks and even so they can tend to be pretty cold. If you're looking for true winter boots I'd recommend Sorrel.
However, just strictly speaking about Hunter boots. Personally I think they're very stiff and VERY heavy as far as rubber boots go. Also, overpriced. After a lot of evaluation I decided to go with the Kamik Jennifer instead which also comes in a short size the Kamik Jenny. They look very similar to the Hunter boots with the exception that they have a slightly narrower shaft, weigh less than half the Hunters do, have a REALLY cushy insole that's amazing and are made out of a slightly softer rubber. I should have done a side-by-side comparison before I mailed the Hunters and the Jenny boots back, but I preferred the two Kamik styles over the two Hunter styles on the basis of comfort, asthetic, weight, fit and price. Oh, did i mention? They're about a third of the price of Hunters. I haven't had the Kamiks too long, but they're very highly rated and almost all the reviews say they last for years. I haven't seen any reports of Kamiks cracking while I've seen lots of reports of Hunters cracking recently.
So there's my two cents. :)
Amazon:
white cropped shrug blazer
white cropped scalloped blazer
white cropped denim jacket
regular denim cropped jacket
​
Amazon (shoes)
Clarks heels (strappy) 3inches ish (I personlly have these & they are incredibly comfortable, I am not a heel person at all and they are my go to (and only pair) of heels) I actually bought them at Winners - I think in the states that would be marshalls or ross?
​
Thick heel sandal -black/brown
Similar to above but all brown
brown sandal with smaller heel
​
honestly it's really up to you! I used clarks as an example because they are crazy comfy and you will have them for a long time! They have a ton of options though, more formal heels, low sandals, wedges, 1-2 inch shoes, etc!
​
Even flats, mules or slides would look really great in my opinion!
Long-time lurker! Hopefully this is the right place to post this....
I need shoe help! My work wardrobe mostly consists of dresses worn with a cardigan (or blazer), and leggings (not tights). I am terrible at shoes, and it's hard to find ones I think are comfortable. I usually wear flats (this is my current pair), or slip-on sneakers. I just tried ordering a bunch of shoes from amazon, flats and wedges, and I'm not in love with any of them.
Should I be looking at booties? I hadn't tried booties because I am really short (4'10") and I have pretty fat ankles/calves. I've looked for taller boots and have never found any I can wear over my giant ankles. But maybe booties would work? My fear was they'd make my legs look even shorter, or would be too tight around my cankles.
Ideally, I'd like something comfortable that I can walk moderate distances in. Also, I suck at heels, so a very short heel or a wedge would be better. And I'm cheap! So under $50? Clearly I'm asking for a miracle here.
A good comfortable pair of flats is very worth it. You can consider it an investment for your professional life. These are comfortable as hell, coming from a woman who wears chuck taylor's every day:
http://www.amazon.com/Hush-Puppies-Womens-Chaste-Ballet/dp/B009OXV0SU
And added bonus they don't have any toe cleavage which grosses some people out.
The standard comfortable heel recommendation on FFA is the Corso Como Del. I tried it on and I fell between sizes because I have the same issue you have (6.5 slips off my heel and a 6 squeezes my toes.). I recommend, if you have a Nordstrom nearby, to go try a pair on and see if they work for your feet.
Since they didn't work for my feet so I ended up purchasing Chinese Laundry Area. The point is more subtle so it isn't outdated and they don't fall off the edge of my heel or squeeze my toes. (though I do sometimes still get minor rubbing so I use moleskin)
Another option is to get a cobbler to stretch out the toe box or do it yourself. I know this will work with leather, and I've heard the you can also do it with patent leather (though patent leather might show "stretched" areas).
My number one park shoes are my Chacos. I love love love them. But they need to be well broken in before a day in the parks.
On my last trip I brought a pair of Sanuk Yoga Sling Sandals, and I loved them! They were super comfy, the sling kept them on, and they dried quickly. And there's so many different colors and patterns!!
Here are some options: first second third fourth
They don't feel any different from my Kamiks, except they're 3x more expensive and have those little white tags on the front.
Hush Puppies Chaste Ballet Flats are my favorite! They are comfy, versatile, and durable.
http://www.amazon.com/Hush-Puppies-Womens-Chaste-Ballet/dp/B009OXV0SU
Items over 10k:
---
Thanks for the contest. You stay classy.
Owners of Corso Como Dels!
Did it take you a few wears to break it in? I have the Corso Como Del in Multi Brown Tortoise Patent and it feels so stiff. I never buy patent leather shoes, so I'm not sure if this is how it is supposed to feel.
You can see here that there is a gap between my heel and the back of the shoe. I think it's because the shoe is so stiff and the heel part is too narrow (like a narrow triangle) and pushes my feet forward, making my toes touch the toe box. Will the triangle part soften and mold to my feet soon?
Not really bottoms, but I've found a pair of knee-high boots always seems to even out my body and make me look longer and slimmer no matter what kind of pants I'm wearing under them- though I tend to favor skinny jeans since they fit under them more comfortably. I have a pair of loose-fit black skinny jeans from Macys and forest green Gap Corduroy skinny pants.
To go over them, I have a pair of Hush Puppies Alternative boots from Macys (most comfy shoes in the world- period), and these hot Miz Mooz boots. The Miz Mooz boots were on sale for 40% off when I got them on Amazon, and I get so many compliments on them!
I'm short (5'2"), but with this combination, I never feel too pear-y or stubby.
Depends on your feet, but I have Dr. Scholls flats on Amazon on my wish list and it sends me a notification when they go on sale, so I never spend more than $30 on any given pair. They last me a long time.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00BTYTRRS/
I'd never heard of Rothy's until I saw your post, and they look so good! I'm going to keep my eyes on those too :)
Fancy!
Wait.. what?
From my wishlist
Over 10K? Fancy!
Good job canceling, those were heinous. To be honest I've never seen a decent looking pair of shoes from Skechers.
Try these: http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B003433FWA
Or these: http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B006GVOUAS
Or if you want boat shoes: http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B000FK5HSU
The Hush Puppies Chaste ballet flat. They have a padded footbed and rubber sole so they're comfortable for walking in but they still have a sleek profile.
[Miz Mooz] (http://www.amazon.com/Miz-Mooz-Womens-Bloom-Knee-High/dp/B003EP3RBC/ref=pd_sbs_shoe_3) These may not be quite what you are looking for but I bought a pair in black last year and wear them all the time. My calf measures 13" and they fit snugly. I managed to get them on sale at $140, making them the priciest pair of shoes I own, but considering how often I wear them I am happy with my splurge and think I will be for a few more years. Happy hunting!
I have these for snow boots, coming from Central New York.
http://www.amazon.com/Columbia-Womens-Ice-Maiden-Winter/dp/B00H7WWN2M
I used to have a pair of Sorel's but the ankle part was cutting into me. These Columbia boots are super comfy, very warm with fluff inside, and have large mobility in the ankle which is unlike most snow boots.
Yes they're online. Price depends, I'd shop around places like 6pm because some colorways are much cheaper than others.
Random Wishes: Whole Foods gift card because I need food.
$15 and under: Macro Lens because I like to take nail/makeup pictures and this is really easy.
Getting Healthy: Shoes because my current sneakers are horrible to walk in.
Accessory/Scarves: Purse because mine is falling apart and my other one broke about a month ago.
Books: Dirty Russian so I can tell people to Fuck off when I study abroad!
Clothes/Shoes: Flip flops because I have none currently and it's almosr summer.
Crafty Hijinks: Colored Pencils because my sil stole all of mine when she moved out.
Debauchery: Love is Art kit because what goes better together than sex and painting?
For the new addition: Newborn photography book so I can take pictures of my nephew!
House/Kitchen: Dehydrator because I love to makeup homemade beef jerky.
Makeup: Betty-Lou Manizer because I want to give one to my momma. Her mom's name was Betty Lou. It's actually the anniversary of her passing tomorrow.
Needed items: Another whole foods gift card. Same reason.
Study Abroad: Suitcase set because my current one is teeny and I'll be gone for 7 months!
hey, are those Canvas Authentic Vans? they look nice. I might consider picking up a pair.
I have some Clarks smoking loafers which are probably my comfiest flats, and these loafers look like they'd be comfy too.
2nd the smoking slippers... I have these ones from Clarks and they are GLORIOUS little foot-clouds, and they look amazing
You definitely needs these pink bear claw slippers in your life! I know I want them in my life!
Happy birthday love! I hope its glittery, fabulous, and filled with food!
Maybe not cat faces, but she can have kitty(ish) feet!
I used to have a pair of these bad boys and they were warm as shit. Unwieldy, though.
Over 10K? Fancy!
Thank you for the contest!
My Gf just picked up a pair of these for some kayaking we did. They're under 6 oz for the pair for women's 8.5, and they're breathable, quick drying, and have a thin rubber sole.
Probably these xD
Link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DZZCTQW
Parentheses after link indicate the relevant WL.
Morthy:
Old posh Englishman! (Miscellaneous)
Never be seen in public, although I would be tempted. (Miscellaneous)
Phallic--NSFW. This was the obvious answer. (NSFW)
Akeleie:
Geeky--this proves what a good wife I'll be. This is on my list for my fiance, but I'm entering it because it fits the best. (Stuff for Hubby)
Goal--I need these hooks so badly! So many projects left unfinished! (Yarn & Supplies)
Deserted island, because it's food! (Miscellaneous)
I wear loafers and ballet flats, I used to wear heels every day but they became too painful. I have these Dr. Scholls flats in Sand Patent and Wine Patent, these Croc flats, and Coach loafers. The Croc flats are super comfy and no one ever guesses they're Crocs! I do not recommend the Coach loafers, they wear out quickly, but I like loafers in general!
I work at a small company producing vintage style t-shirts(read: american apparel tri-blends with hand screened prints). We wear our product all the time to help promote ourselves, which basically includes jeans and a t-shirt. I dont really have shoes to complete the look though. Its been fine so far because i just wear sandals all the time since it was summer, but now that its cooling off, i want to find a pair of nice, versatile shoes for the rest of the year.
I was looking at something like these: http://www.zappos.com/saucony-originals-jazz-low-pro-vegan-grey-red
Or These: http://www.amazon.com/Vans-AUTHENTIC-SKATE-SHOES-PEWTER/dp/B003433FWA/ref=sr_1_47?s=shoes&ie=UTF8&qid=1381235760&sr=1-47
Im just not sure. Ive got a laid back personality and i think that reflects on my personal style, but i want to get something that goes with a lot of colors, will hold up against snow, and still looks nice without breaking the bank. Does anyone have suggestions?
I have the charlie brogue. It looks like they currently have these available, but patent leather can easily get scuffed. Other quality comfort brands to consider are Born and Bass. Looks like you should be able to find something for 100-150(USD).
Sebago penny loafers! I have the brown and love them dearly.
Oh I'm so glad I clicked on this thread! I've been looking for a comfy and super light pair of shoes to replace my Reeboks that I can no longer find in the right size or color, these look like a good idea!!
Sanuk yoga sandals amazon link
Might be too casual for you but these come up a little higher and hide ankle socks better than vans/keds. They are also SUPER comfy (no break ins needed, and I get blisters from almost every shoe) and machine washable.
Price History
CamelCamelCamel - [Info] │ Keepa - [Info]
_
Don't En Passant these deals.
^(Info) ^| ^(Developer) ^| ^(Inquiries) ^| ^(Support Me!) ^| **[^(Report Bug)](/message/compose?to=The_White_Light&subject=Bug+Report&message=%2Fr%2Famazondealsus%2Fcomments%2Fcq6kc3%2Fzriey_womens_gladiator_flat_sandals_70nkc9kl70%2Fewu8s3f%2F%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0APlease+explain+here+what+you+expected+to+happen%2Fwhat+went+wrong.)**
I don't wear heels either because they're just not suited for me/my life.
For work - Hush Puppies Chilli because I'm a pharmacist = on my feet all day. My next purchase for work are compression stockings. The hush puppies are almost dead so I'll need to get some more work shoes soon too.
Casual -
Miz Mooz has some similar boots: here and here
I bought these amazing boots and they are my favorite things ever. They aren't bulky at all. They are lightweight, fashionable, and will keep you toasty warm and dry. I know they aren't cheap but online black friday deals are going to be coming out soon. I got mine on sale and they are worth every single penny. New England winters suck too so, I feel your pain there. I hope you find everything you are looking for!
These ones. It's kind of hard to see in the photo but if you look at the various angles, you can kinda see the arch support.
I feel really bad for this one, but...
If a polar bear was next to a bomb when it went off, and the bear exploded, this is all that would be left.
Sorry it's kind of morbid :X
Change Jar!
I have these oxfords in black and I'd definitely recommend them.
People on drugs like shit that lights up in general, hahaha. I'm a guy and always would get tons of compliments on my light up shoes.
I had these ones from Amazon.
Hi a guy and always would get tons of compliments on my light up shoes.
I had these ones from Amazon., I'm dad!
I have footie pajamas and slippers on my wishlist. They would help me relax and just breathe because I'm ALWAYS cold. I even moved to Texas to avoid being cold. =[ Texas is a fair bit warmer than Ohio though!!
Thanks for all your suggestions! I just got a pair of Columbia Ice Maiden II Winter Boots and also a pair of Minnetonka Cally mocs. Here's to toasty warm feet!