Reddit reviews Action Comics Annual #1 guest starring Superman and Batman!

While I liked John Byrne's revamp overall, it's pretty much the version of Superman that I grew up with, I always felt that this was the weak link in that first 6-issue miniseries. The issue starts off good, and I liked the setup of Superman flying to Gotham to capture Batman, thinking he's just some dangerous vigilante, I always felt that Magpie was a pretty weak adversary for the "first" team up of these iconic characters. And even as a kid I thought Batman's internal monologue about how "in a different reality, we could have been friends" felt like forced reference to the post-Crisis continuity. I think the story he wrote in Action Comics Annual #1 was a much better team-up.