Reddit reviews HON YOSHIHIDE 10 Pcs Chisel Set in Wooden Box, Engraving Knife, Edge Material : SK5 Steel
We found 2 Reddit comments about HON YOSHIHIDE 10 Pcs Chisel Set in Wooden Box, Engraving Knife, Edge Material : SK5 Steel. Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.
Made in Japan ! The set includes; As this is handmade, it could have some small scratches, flaws or bent. We do not recommend this for those who do not like those small irregularities. We recommend this to those who really understand the merits of handmade product tempered by Japanese craftsmen. We will not accept any return requests and claims on the above points for this product.1. U-Shaped Gouge 3mm(0.1inch), 2. U-Shaped Gouge 6mm(0.2inch), 3.U-Shaped Gouge 9mm(0.4inch),4. V-Shaped Gouge4.5mm(0.2inc), 5. Seal-Engraving Knife 7.5mm(0.3inch) [Left],6. Seal-Engraving Knife 7.5mm(0.3inch) , 7. Seal-Engraving Knife 4.5mm(0.2inch)8.Flat 4.5mm(0.2inch), 9.Flat 7.5mm(0.3inch), 10.Flat U-Shaped Gouge 9mm(0.4inch)
Would these tools at amazon be comparable to the ones you listed?
https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B008349HCC
They look really similar - just not sure if quality be same. I was looking at some netsuke carving - these looks amazing and they do require harder wood. Recently i tried carving crow from monument valley out of hard ebony wood and i damaged my felxcut knife.
I feel it important to mention that, while the set you suggested is definitely high quality, it is meant for different materials and uses than the kind of knives OP originally bought.
If OP is learning a particular style or wants that particular kind of tool, There are lots of other good potential sets they can buy:
Example Beginner's Set
Example Intermediate Set
I got started with something very similar to the beginner's set, and my teacher thought those were fine to carve in yew and see if I liked it as a hobby.