Reddit reviews MSR Hubba Hubba NX 2-Person Lightweight Backpacking Tent, Without Xtreme Waterproof Coating
We found 6 Reddit comments about MSR Hubba Hubba NX 2-Person Lightweight Backpacking Tent, Without Xtreme Waterproof Coating. Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.
3-season, 2-person backpacking tent that offers the most livable accommodations in a lightweight freestanding designPole geometry maximizes space with 29 sq. feet of floor area, interior peak height of 39 inches, plus 17. 5 sq. feet of vestibule areaComplete setup weighs 3. 9 lbs. and packs down to 18x6 inches; minimalist setup option uses footprint, poles, and rainfly and weighs 3. 5 lbs.Includes DuraShield Coating and DAC Featherlike NFL polesIncludes tent, one unified hub-and-pole system, rainfly, stakes, and guy lines; footprint sold separately; manufacturer’s 3-year limited
Well if your desired price is $288, it's showing as $228 for me on Amazon right now.
*edit - it's back up to $299 already
I own a Nemo Dagger 2P (last year's design), and I'd say the only shortcomings are ventilation and vestibule door height. If you have all 8 corners of the fly staked down, it's a bit tricky to maneuver into the door. For ventilation, it'll only ever be an issue if you've got the rain fly totally sealed up (as we did in a recent trip with heavy overnight rain). Other than that, it's a great freestanding tent!
My #2 choice was the MSR Hubba Hubba NX 2, which is very similar to the Dagger. Last year's version is actually $100 off on Amazon Prime right now: https://www.amazon.com/MSR-Hubba-2-Person-Lightweight-Backpacking/dp/B00G7H9CAY?th=1 I'd wager that the savings are worth it compared to the Dagger, which currently is $400. I even convinced one of my friends to take advantage of the Amazon deal earlier this week, so I'll have a chance to do a direct comparison this weekend!
The MSR Hubba Hubba is $287 on Amazon now, from the usual MSRP of $399
https://www.amazon.com/MSR-Hubba-NX-Tent-Red/dp/B00G7H9CAY/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1467941295&sr=8-1&keywords=Hubba+hubba
Very much agree with this, even if it doesn't rain you're going to have to worry about dew. If you go ahead and purchase one of these, make sure that you don't sleep with anything in contact with the walls of the tent, I guarantee you will wake up moist if you do.
To add a bit more, there are a few things to think about. At least this is my two cents.
There is very much a difference between "Water Resistant" and "Water Proof." Items that are "water resistant" could be made of waterproof materials, but they will still let in water through the seams. Specifically related to the two tents that you linked, I would be highly suspicious that those seams aren't going to either tear open or let the elements in through the corners. "Water Proof" typically means that that the seams are sealed, which means that the seams are coated in plastic on the inside of the tent. Be sure to look for the key words "seam sealed!"
Another thing to think about when looking at these tents is the risk that the rain fly comes into contact with the actual tent. A rain fly that sticks to the wall of the tent it basically worthless.
Those are two things to think about from a utility perspective, there are certainly more, but being able to get a bug free, dry night's of sleep is usually that one thing (for me personally) that really transitions the experience from "roughing it" to adventuring.
I have an MSR Hubba Hubba and I LOVE it. It incorporates all of the stuff above with most of the extra gravy that I could ever ask for. It fits two people, but is still light enough to go on solo trips. The frame is one piece so not as much to lose and takes no more than 5 minutes to set up. The rainfly creates a vestibule on each side where you actually store your gear. This is not something that is typically thought about when purchasing your first tent, but being able to keep your pack outside of the tent while you stretch out is pretty boss.
This being the case, a Hubba Hubba will run you about $400, and it seems that you're likely not looking to spend that much. I've never used a Kelty tent, but a Kelty pack got me through the entirety of my scouting years. Hardy gear that saves you a bit of money because they don't include a lot of the frills. I'm looking at this Kelty Acadia 2 and it really doesn't look bad at all for 100 bucks. What's the difference between this and the $400 Hubba Hubba? Notice that the specs say "Taped floor seams" and not "seam sealed." This means that the floor seams have had plastic tape adhered to them, but they haven't had plastic heat bonded to the seam. Both are waterproof, but tape likely won't last as long. You'll also notice that the Hubba Hubba is only 3 pounds where this is 7. Those 4 pounds are worth the extra $300 when you are doing 15-20 miles a day, but I doubt that's your current state if you are looking at $25 tents. $100 may be outside of your budget, but I guarantee you that you would enjoy the experience more and that it will last a LOT longer.
Cheers!
Sad to see that it's $309 on Amazon Prime now. I snagged it just 10 days ago for $228.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00G7H9CAY/
Check out MSR Hubba Hubba those are awesome: light weight, durable, and worth every penny. If you were in US, I’d suggest an REI brand tent, which could save some money.