Reddit reviews Next Level Mens Premium Fitted Short-Sleeve Crew T-Shirt - Large - Heather Grey

I had the same issue. After a lot of research, I found these. I've been really happy with them. CHEAP too. =)

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B008KE4SDI/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o06_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I originally saw the link for these shirts in an old Off-Topic thread:

This T-shirt in Navy, Olive, Light Gray, & Dark Gray

I used to just grab either the Uniqlo solid T's or J Crew factory, and I like these a lot better and they're mad cheap. For size reference, I'm 6' 215 and wear a large in this shirt. My chest measurement is something like 44", and it fits tight, but not shockingly tight around the chest and hangs with a taper without hugging my torso like an underarmour shirt. Arms might be tight for some people; I've got super long arms, so un-flexed they aren't as thick as some of these other guys, but the arm holes are pretty snug still.