Best eye makeup remover according to redditors
We found 78 Reddit comments discussing the best eye makeup remover. We ranked the 33 resulting products by number of redditors who mentioned them. Here are the top 20.
We found 78 Reddit comments discussing the best eye makeup remover. We ranked the 33 resulting products by number of redditors who mentioned them. Here are the top 20.
Something a little less traditional.
Product name: Ocusoft Foaming Lid Scrub
Product type: Foaming Eyelid Cleanser
Price (range): ~$20 for 7.25oz Amazon, also available at some Walgreens locations and doctor's offices.
Country of purchase: USA
Skin info: Normal, Fitzpatrick 2, very mildly PD/eczema/rosacea-prone
Ingredient list: Water, PEG-80,
Sorbitan Laurate, SodiumTrideceth Sulfate, Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine, PEG-150 Distearate, Sodium Lauroamphoacetate, Sodium Laureth-13 Carboxylate, Sodium Chloride, 1,2 Hexanediol, Caprylyl Glycol, Polyaminopropyl Biguanide, Potassium Sorbate, PEG-15 Cocopolyamine
Special info:
Experience & opinion: After hours of
researchfrantic googling, and in a desperate attempt to ease my eyelid inflammation earlier this year, I picked this up.It's a very soft, pre-lathered foam meant specifically to clean eyelids and the lash line, particularly geared toward people who have easily irritated, inflamed, or infection-prone eyelids. As advertised on the bottle it removes oil, debris & desquamated skin, and effectively removes cosmetics.
I ended up really liking this stuff and it gives me peace of mind that I'm thoroughly and safely cleaning my eyelids without exacerbating my problems. It also does a good job removing eye makeup so I'm not going to bed with mascara still in my lash line.
I use 1 pump per eye, focusing a lot on my lashes and lash line. I'll likely re-buy considering how long it's lasted—I'm still using my first bottle from mid-July, with at least once, sometimes twice, a day usage.
Obviously, there's other less expensive options to remove eye makeup if that's all you need, but if you have irritated lids or you're looking for something specifically meant for eyelid hygiene, I'd give it a try.
Edited for clarity.
I haven't tried the Too Faced Mascara Melt Off but I use a similar product (KIss Me Heroine Make Mascara Remover) and it's the best remover I've ever had. Swipe it on like mascara and in less than a minute I can just blot off even the strongest waterproofs... and it's less than half the cost of the Too Faced one.
And for the most waterproof mascara I've ever encountered, I recommend Heroine Make Kiss Me mascara which is actually so waterproof that you need their special mascara remover. You could swim across the Pacific and it wouldn't come off.
[Also, as a female almost-MS2 currently doing an IM preceptorship, this makes me feel less ridiculous for putting on makeup every day so I don't scare off people.]
Just in case you might want to know... When I need to use a q-tip for fixing errors, I just use these. You get a lot for $15, and they're super easy to use. You just snap one end, and the makeup remover flows into the other tip. You won't have to worry about getting q-tips and remover out and messing with all that, and you won't have to lick another q-tip ever again! I love these things. They're awesome.
Your face is a canvas and the make-up is like paint. Think about painting in layers if that helps.
That being said, here's my recommendation. You skin is your canvas so you gotta take care of it. Pay attention to your body/skin, everyone is different so use what is working for you. Exfoliate regularly, exfoliating helps clear up pores and scrub away dead skin. I do it daily, again do as much as your own skin needs to. My pores tend to clog easily so I try my best to keep it clean. I use something like this, just a slightly rougher bath sponge, squeeze a little face wash on it and lightly scrub - again this is what I do, your mileage may vary.
Regardless of how oily your skin is, moisturize it. If you have naturally oilier skin like me, use a lighter moisturizer (it feels lighter on your skin not as thick or creamy). conversely, use a heavier moisturizer if you tend to have dry skin. It doesn't necessarily have to be a "face moisturizer" product, lotions work also i've noticed. The point of all this is you want a clean and hydrated skin, it looks younger and healthier. I use, Aveeno's Men's After Shave Lotion. It get's two birds with one stone for me, aftershave plus helps keep my skin hydrated and is on the lighter side (won't feel greasy when it dries.)
The next layer in the painting would be concealer and foundation. Concealers are more pigmented "cover up" work. Using me again, i have slight rosatia/pinkness, concealers help neutralize out the redness to a more even skin tone. Foundation is a less pigmented but does the same thing essentially. Go to a Walgreen's or any drugstore and just look at the color samples. You'll want to color match to your neck so that your general face color blends in with your neck. Taking care of you skin takes time to get but when you get there you shouldn't need much concealer or foundation to even out your face. I like BB Cream No. 23, Natural Biege, matches my color fairly well.
You can pick either of those up or an equivalent product at any drugstore. People won't give you any grief, it's not too common but some males do buy coverup/concealers for acne breakouts so it shouldn't cause too much fuss to buy in person.
As far as applying blush, eyeshadow, liner brows ... the works, it's hard to type out and is best if shown to you. Beating a dead horse, watch the you tube videos and practice putting them on. You WILL get better. I did a quick look through amazon, this Shany Set seems like an okay kit. It has a various color pots to play/practice with. (color pot, the little containers that the actual make up sits in.) Your small round pots are your eyeshadows and the large round ones are your blushes. It looks like it comes with the applicators too, the fancy q-tip looking things are for eyeshadows and the bristle brush for blush. It also has the standard black and brown pencil eye liner, a pencil lip liner, lipstick and some nailpolish.
When it's all said and done, you've read all that you can or watched all the videos you've cared to watch. My best advice I can give you is take care of your skin and practice. Keep putting it on, get a feel for it and learn how certain things get applied. Eyeliner for example, you need to get used to the fact that there's something that close to your eye when you're trying to put it on. With time and practice it gets easier, your hand gets steadier and your eyes don't flinch as much.
Not my best nor my worst, but here's where i'm at on a typical day. http://i.imgur.com/C1vPsxg.jpg
Lastly, baby wipes or makeup remover wipes is good for taking it all off and these on a cotton swab is good to remove eyeliner without any trace.
Edit: words and links
Hap hap hello there! I am a bot and you linked to Amazon.
This comment contains 2 pricing graph(s)
____
Product 1: Skin Food Peach Sake Pore Serum 45ml Made in 'Korea (B004S3M2V0)
Imgur pricing graph
||Amazon|3P New|Used|
|--:|:--|:--|:--|
|Cur||$9.55||
|Hi||$15.59||
|Lo||$3.46||
|Avg||$9.51||
____
Product 2: [Total 2Pcs] The Face Shop Rice Water Bright Cleansing Oil + Foam SET (B00SUZWGHM)
Imgur pricing graph
||Amazon|3P New|Used|
|--:|:--|:--|:--|
|Cur||$13.20||
|Hi||$20.98||
|Lo||$10.70||
|Avg||$13.49||
_____
^^I'm ^^a ^^bot. ^^Please ^^PM ^^any ^^bugs
This is some truly wonderful stuff. It has turned me into everything from a 62-year-old Jewish man to a perverted innkeeper and everything in between (on-stage of course..)
And someone else over there just rec'd their dedicated Mascara Remover which I have not personally tried but I have generally heard is a good product :)
Now that's one thing from TFS I won't change reguardless of what people have said about TFS. This set I havent changed in over a year and probably wont. I love how light it is and the subtle sent is amazing. My daughter uses the oil on her acne prone skin with no issues as well. She uses Benton Honest cleansing foam though. Ive been shopping for a new sunscreen though so I dont mind changing that to cosrx.
Edit- words
kiss me heroine super waterproof mascara! Just make sure to pack a biphase eye makeup remover like this one: https://www.amazon.com/Bifesta-Mandom-Makeup-Remover-145ml/dp/B005F2EVMQ
Oil cleansing is the best, I don’t regret it. It removes everything easily and after I follow up with my regular cleanser. Is important to use a cleanser afterwards to remove the oil and everything with it. I use either the face shop rice water bright cleansing foam or cerave hydrating cleanser. The face shop brand is korean, the oil is called the face shop facial cleanser natural rice water light cleansing oil. I buy both of them at amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/Water-Bright-Cleansing-Moisturizing-Brightening/dp/B00SUZWGHM/ref=sr_1_4_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1519787656&sr=1-4&keywords=The+face+shop
I've also had a reaction to the Garnier Micellar Water as well as the Simple Micellar Water. Despite the brand getting some shit on this sub, I love the Cetaphil Makeup Remover. I also use Clinique Take the Day Off balm if I'm wearing a lot of foundation/sunscreen, but I don't like using balms/oils for my eyes since I wear contacts. I've tried quite a few of eye makeup removers and this is the only one that doesn't cause a reaction.
That Heroine mascara is so good and stays on forever! Did you happen to get the remover too? It's so hard to take off without it!
The Face Shop cleansing oil, followed by The Face Shop rice water cleansing foam. It's a Korean brand and you can find a bundle with both for like $15 on Amazon. Both will last you a while too; the foam will outlast the oil by two or three times as long. And what's great is that Amazon has bundles of them so when you need to replenish it won't break the bank :)
I'm not prone to styes, but I did have an eyelid issue a couple years ago and discovered Ocusoft Lid Scrub Plus pads. You can often find them in the drugstore and they feel incredible!
If you're that worried about removing mascara, they do sell mascara removers that come in tubes. I've been using the Too Faced one that came in my Sephora Play box, but a quick google search has pointed to at least one other.
Could try OCuSOFT lid wipes
https://www.amazon.com/OCuSOFT-Scrub-Plus-Pre-Moistened-Count/dp/B000US084U
Wipe eyelids before putting cream or ointment. Can buy OTC.
I get eczema in the corners of my eyes too, and this helps a little
I use cold-pressed pumpkin seed oil for my whole face but if I'm lazy, just a Neutrogena wipe. If you're looking for something that works really well for waterproof mascara, I recommend the Kiss Me Heroine Make Speedy Mascara Remover.
I LOVE my Clarisonic. I know there are mixed reviews here, but I work in gross-ass theaters/outside/am sweaty, in addition to living in NYC and I wanna be clean.
Balm's Away makes waterproof/long wear anything wash right away.
Purity cleanser is another culty thing, but seriously, melts off make up, without that gross stripped feeling. And it smells nice.
Skinceuticals C E Ferulic in the AM and Nude Treatment Oil at night have made huge strides in not only my moisture level, but also my gross cystic acne scars. Without my face looking like an oil slick/aggravating my sensitive/acne-prone skin.
CeraVe In The Tub is as good as everyone says
Korres Wild Rose Brightening Eye Cream is MAGIC if you have dark circles. MAGIC.
Origins Clear Improvements is my go to "I'm going out and don't want people to see my SF's" mask. It sucks everything out (and brings lurkers to a head), and makes me look flawless, at least for the day.
hope that helps :)
Hey everyone!
I just bought a Hada Labo Hyaluronic lotion to incrorporate it into my skin care. My skin is kinda sensitive normal(not too oily and not too dry). I don't have much acne. My main purpose is to have healthy skin and slow aging process :) What I use now is:
Morning:
- Cleanse with water
- Apply some Aloe vera gel
- Sunscreen (reaply throughout the day if needed)
Night:
- Double cleanse ( The Face Shop Rice Water Bright Cleansing Oil + Foam Set by The Face )
- One day I do retinol serum (link), another day I do AHA tonic. I am afraid of using them together
- Wait for 20-40 mins
- Apply Crazy Skin Korea/Trouble Care Sleeping Cream (link)
I feel like I need more moisture (especially in the morning) so I want to integrate it into my routine. Can you reccomend where should I squeeze it?
Thanks! :D
I use this mascara remover. I have to use a bottom and top coat plus super waterproof mascara or it smears everywhere and this remover has been a lifesaver. It comes in a tube like regular mascara which makes it easy to coat on the lashes. I just apply it on my lashes before oil cleansing, then go about oil cleansing my face as per usual saving my eye area for last. By the time I get to my eyes the oil has sat long enough that all my mascara comes off very easily. I have a suspicion that the same effect could be achieved by putting a normal oil cleanser in an empty mascara tube but I haven't tried that yet since I still have plenty of my remover to get through. My theory is that the main reason this works so well compared to a normal oil cleanser is that the brush allows you to really coat each lash fully with the cleanser. Kinda like how some people use a wide toothed comb in the shower to distribute conditioner in their hair.
I've personally never used Lid Care Solution, but I use these and they work pretty well for me. They're normally $20 on Amazon and in stores, but they're on sale now!
If you get them all the time maybe try adding this to your routine. Ocusoft Lid Scrub Foaming Eyelid Cleanser, 7.25 Fluid Ounce https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000A7VRYG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_X64wDbWWSNV6Q
These bamboo ones have the best reviews on Amazon and come with a little mesh bag to toss them into the laundry.
There are also the microfiber ones with more reviews and slightly cheaper, but I personally don't like microfiber so that's up to your preferences.
The Face Shop Rice Water Bright Cleansing Foam and oil. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00SUZWGHM/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_5E6fAb4F2NCVA
Howdy, tinyblondehuman. This item is the cheapest by price. However, this Keurig variety pack would really tickle my fancy (plus free shipping with Prime). Thanks for the contest!
I started AB last year and I still haven't been able to add a sunscreen to my routine because of all the [failed] patch testing.
I bought a Missha All Around Safe Block Essence Sun SPF45 and broke out from it. But I didn't have an oil cleanser when I tried it, which could possibly be the reason.
Every "oily" product seems to break me out (Cerave in the tub, Cerave lotion, Cerave Hydrating Cleanser, Secret Key Lemon Sparkling Cleansing Oil, Kose Softymo Speedy). The only moisturizer that has worked for me so far is a gel one (Mizon Snail Recovery), so my guess is that my skin hates oils.
But then how will I get fully remove AB sunscreen?
I was wanting to try this, but I'm not sure if it could do the job: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00IWUXGUQ/_encoding=UTF8?coliid=I2F6DP5Q152MUN&colid=1EF0C9QIERENV
I use Bifesta Eye Makeup Remover. I typically put it on a cotton pad and then press it gently against my eye for at least 30 seconds, per eye. It does a pretty good job. I switched from a Neutrogena eye make up remover because it was irritating my eyes too and Bifesta does not.
I started off with Oasis eyelid wipes (non-tea tree), which I got from my eye doctor's office, but when I ran out of those, I tried the tea tree kind which I like a lot better.
https://www.amazon.com/Oasis-LASH-Tree-Eyelid-Cleansing/dp/B077YNRSB2/
Cheaper versions like OcuSoft also work, but I found OcuSoft to be a bit too rough and not quite as moisturizing - haven't tried other brands. I cut the Oasis ones in halves to last longer (I use one side of the half for one eye and the other side for the other eye).
As for eyeliner, I haven't tried wearing any with the tea tree ones, but I wore it just fine with the regular version, so I don't see how it would be any different. I do use all waterproof eye makeup though since I wear contacts.
I want to glue things on my face.. This is on my cosplay list.
8 lbs 1 oz
I actually need to pick up a new bottle, but for removing stubborn mascara (including the heroine make long & curl super waterproof), I swear by the etude house mascara remover.
If curious, the products I noticed =
Skin Food Peach Sake Pore Serum
I ordered for 7.90, now 10.98
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004S3M2V0/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&th=1
The Face Shop Rice Water Bright Cleansing Oil + Foam SET
I remember being about $11-13, now 15.97
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00SUZWGHM/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o05_s05?ie=UTF8&psc=1
My skin is kinda sensitive, and I enjoy using a variety of cleaners - but the wipes don't usually do well with my skin. My favorite for makeup is Sephora's make up remover, esp the eye make up remover liquid. I also like the face shop rice water cleanser set, because it has an oil cleanser you use with a normal soap cleaner you get a moist and smooth clean and the makeup really comes off well. I got the set based off someone's rec here actually. When I'm not wearing heavy makeup I often just use this swedish bar soap, which is very nice and doesn't irritate my skin.
I use a makeup remover wipe to get most of my makeup off, then I go in with a separate makeup remover (theBalm's or Maybelline ) and use the wipe to remove everything.
I would urge you to remove wipes from your regimen. People -usually- are too rough while using them, unintentionally. Use the lotion version of the hydrating cleanser wipes, instead. You rub it in, and then can use camp cotton rounds to GENTLY sweep off the makeup. Especially great for the eye area; all the pulling and tugging you do with these is so bad for your face.
Neutrogena Hydrating Makeup Remover Lotion:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0037MQAE8/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_VMieBbAP8FGNZ
Neither.
I use Albolene. It's a makeup remover that you can buy at like WallGreens Pharmacy in the Beauty Care Section.
Its primary ingredients are: Mineral Oil, Petrolatum, and Beta Carotene.
Seriously... Someone mentioned this stuff deep in the bowls of www.jackinworld.com re: Sex Toys and/or Lube Recipes that you can make from household items. One person basically said that there was some kind of "Gooning Organization" in New York and everyone swears by it because it repels precum and you can jerk with it for hours upon hours and as long as you occasionally wipe away any precum... you'll never rub yourself raw.
If you want to check it out... this is what it looks like:
https://www.amazon.com/Albolene-Moisturizing-Cleanser-6-Ounce/dp/B000L1AY3G/ref=sr_1_1_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1487338187&sr=1-1&keywords=albolene
Also... they recently started making a version of it specifically for removing eye makeup... and in my opinion, it's even better than the original [travel size FTW]
https://www.amazon.com/Albolene-Makeup-Remover-0-85-Ounce/dp/B01MTDHFK3/ref=pd_sim_194_1?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B01MTDHFK3&pd_rd_r=W7BM5MPV7657K8M9V3GR&pd_rd_w=qhUpc&pd_rd_wg=2Euu6&psc=1&refRID=W7BM5MPV7657K8M9V3GR
I really like this one, which is sometimes sold in a set with Kiss Me Heroine mascaras.
The Korean brand COSRX makes some great, sensitive products with AHA and BHA. Using products with tea tree oil might help, but be wary of anything that could potentially alter your hormone profile. The basics of Korean skin care are consistent, everyday use of a clear step-by-step process. I suggest this site for how-to.
You don't need every step necessarily, but I would start slowly with 3-4 and build up slowly as to not agitate your skin. The important ones for you are going to be the two part cleansing, toning, essence, spot treatments and ampules, and light moisturizer-- so about six of the steps or so.
Here are some things that I find help, and seem to be very popular for acne prone skin. I have used all these, as well as my sensitive, acne prone DH and had success:
Finally, be very careful ordering similar "discount" products off amazon because it is rife with counterfeits from China. This can be dangerous as the contents of the product/ingredients are not necessarily listed correctly, which is a problem. Buying reputable brands from verified sellers or soko glam or Sephora is absolutely recommended. I get a lot of Amazon, but I always use Fakespot.com and also check the seller out carefully. If the well-known brand manufacturer is selling it direct to Amazon, that is a pretty safe bet.
All of these thing start with the skin down, but also consider the bottom up. Look at your diet, look at your activity level, how often you clean your sheets, how stressed you are, and your general health. Have you been evaluated for gynecological or endocrine issues? It's a good idea to know that before you jump to conclusion. Make sure to consult a doctor, because sometimes our skin is a good indication of something off inside.
Good luck and I am sorry you are suffering!
do you use the rice water bright one? (pink)
i'm going to switch to this from that as well, but if you ever use a similar product again, keep the plastic bit it comes with to prevent the pump from going down. glossier's body oil has one too.
e: ALSO if you/anyone else sees this, amazon has the foaming + oil cleansers as a pair for like $14 here, since you said you paid $12 for just the oil cleanser :c
https://www.amazon.com/Cetaphil-Gentle-Waterproof-Makeup-Remover/dp/B01M31HY3S/ref=sr_1_10_s_it?s=beauty&ie=UTF8&qid=1506192735&sr=1-10&keywords=makeup+remover
Second this! Was actually about to post this myself :)
I've been using the cleansing oil and face wash set for a few months now and I've noticed a massive difference in my skin texture and tone.
The heroine mascara remover. That mascara is life proof but this still gets it off.
https://www.amazon.com/KISS-HEROINE-Makeup-Remover-110ml/dp/B007152KGE
Does anyone know if this Isehan heroine make mascara remover in tube form is the same as this formula in the bottle? I love the wand applicator to directly apply it on my lashes and if it's the same I'll just decant into the tube :D
Heroine has their own mascara remover. It works pretty well but... if you wear Heroine everyday, you'll run out of it quickly.
What I do now is wearing a lash primer (Etude House dr. mascara fixer) before applying Heroine. By the end of the night, I use an oil cleanser and slather it all over my lashes. I wait 5 minutes then it removes completely. No rubbing needed.
I've looked at it before, and it seems the company makes a specific makeup cleanser for that product? Have you tried that?
I sound like a broken record recommending the Heroine mascara remover but it starts dissolving their waterproof mascara immediately! (Not sure about this version, bought mine in Japan and the tube is blue.)
I spent years avoiding waterproof mascara for fear of losing even more of my invisible blonde, straight, non-existent lashes, but this is a lifesaver!
Hey I don't know if you're still looking (I arrived on this post checking your history on leaving LLR). I've recently started using products from The face shop (actual name). It's a Korean brand and I ordered from Amazon after seeing some reviews a bit of everywhere.
It's quite amazing, I bought this pack (European version of Amazon, it's probably available for your area too): The Face Shop [Total 2Pcs] Rice Water Bright Cleansing Oil + Foam SET https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B00SUZWGHM/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_yqHDAbSFE0E7H
It's a cleansing product. If you're looking for moisturizing stuff, I go with neutrogena (for the body) and mixa (for the face). I have a normal skin type, non oily, but with dry tendencies in winter. I also use a body butter 2 times a week, from nspa.
funny enough I use an oil free cleanser my wife uses on her eyelashes. I just put a little on a q tip or soft rag and wipe them down, seems to be working...
I have the black/grey joycons but have not had any degradation using it to clean, cant speak for the colored ones
https://www.amazon.com/Lash-Love-Extension-Foaming-Cleanser/dp/B07B5FW473
I use micellar water too, and I would do a second cleansing with an oil cleanser which took off the remaining mascara without any harsh rubbing!
They also make a specific remover if you want to try that out!
GREAT haul! I love Lunasol, it's one of my favorite eyeshadow brands of all time (the others being Kate, also from Kanebo, and MUFE). I haven't tried the Velvetful Eyes series but I've tried their Skin Modeling Eyes, Scent Form Eyes, and 3 Dimensional Eyes series. My favorite is Beige Bronze (LE) from Skin Modeling Eyes. Also, Bifesta makes my all time favorite eye makeup remover. I've tried a lot of Japanese and Western eye makeup removers and that one is HG status. Let me know how the Bright Up Cleansing Lotion is!
I also see Majolica Majorca Lash Expander! They're constantly coming out with new versions of it. I got Lash Expander Frame Plus awhile back and have yet to use it but yea, MM makes my favorite mascaras of all time too :) You have made very nice choices!
PS: don't feel too bad about the haul, you got everything on sale :D I spent ahem a lot of money recently on makeup and Japanese makeup brushes too XD
>But a move?
Yes, it happened to me.
>And are there any remedies beyond warm compresses and eyelid cleanser?
I struggled with it for about a year... what finally did the trick was using this product for about a month. Got it under control then finally fully disappeared after a month or two extra of use. Never had it again since. They also have the plus version which is for more severe cases. The "Plus" version can be kept on, while the normal version needs to be washed off. Think they also have some eyelid wipes which contain the formula in it but I never tried those.
Anyway, strongly recommend you try that product - the reviews speak for themselves and I personally vouch for it.
Good luck, Blepharitis is a fucking shit condition and when it's really bad makes you look like shit and feel like shit, I hated it to the max.