Best slip & martingale collars according to redditors
We found 29 Reddit comments discussing the best slip & martingale collars. We ranked the 24 resulting products by number of redditors who mentioned them. Here are the top 20.
We found 29 Reddit comments discussing the best slip & martingale collars. We ranked the 24 resulting products by number of redditors who mentioned them. Here are the top 20.
You would benefit from using a collar with a release.
Something with a release like this will allow you to undo the collar in an emergency (for example, if the collar is caught on something and choking). My dog has actually been able to get his tag stuck between the boards of my deck when he was laying down on it and I was glad to have this. These will also last a long time and some have lifetime warranties, such as Lupine, which offers an "even if chewed" replacement warranty. I bought a cheap one (not Lupine) over a decade ago and am still using it on my malamute without problem. Actually, the only reason I have ever replaced these are because the dog outgrew it or I wanted to change the color.
Something like this is more difficult to remove.
If you are using something more like this, then it would be very difficult. These can also cause damage to the dog's throat which can result in expensive vet bills.
The tool you would need to remove a collar would be dependent on what the collar was made out of. A nylon webbing one would be removable with scissors while a leather one might require a knife and a metal one would require a bolt cutter. A nylon collar with a release like the first one linked should put you in a position where you do not have to worry about this, though.
I had the same issue with my pei, only collar she can wear is a chain. We use a harness on walks. I would try a chain type collar, you shouldn't have problems :) I've bought from this company a few times.. My pei is a girl so of course she needed a pink collar :)
Platinum Pets 4mm Coated Chain Dog Collar 20-Inch, Bubblegum Pink https://www.amazon.com/dp/B003ZKEQA2/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_-T35BbHT64V57
Corgis are pretty stout, like small big dogs. On ours we use a small choke chain.
time for a martingale collar
GSDs are really big dogs, I would recommend if your corrections don't seem to be working, get a martingale or pincher collar. If used properly it is not going to hurt them, just provide more disincentives for pulling.
Some will say that collars like these are abusive, but if you use them properly they are a great training aid. You have to understand that a dog's neck is much different than a human's, so the prongs are not painful to them.
So, you're looking for a collar that doesn't use a quick release buckle and a hands free type leash without the talan/lobster claw clasp?
How about a martingale collar. They can be somewhat difficult to get on and off and shouldn't be left on when the dog isn't supervised. Or a buckle collar. This might not be a good idea though if your dog doesn't like the collar to be messed around with since you would need to buckle it every time.
Drag free leashes
Is there a reason you dont like harnesses?
Actually - the one we use isn’t very expensive and I’ve used it now for 10 months. I didn’t want to go with something more expensive the first go around as I wasn’t sure I would like it. I adjusted it to make sure it fit right with help of our trainers. He’s tested the sturdiness of it a few times thanks to rabbits in our front yard and it’s held up.
Mighty Paw Martingale Collar - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N5MQ2E8/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apip_Ni3IVq6meZiJx
Some of the dogs in my ‘extended’ breeder family have discount codes for Sexy Beast. I’ve debated on upgrading my male to that since he’s 18 months and should be fully grown now. I’ve also looked at 2 Hound Designs for my Show Girl as they have cute options which seems to be hard to find some days.
Metal collar they can't chew through?
Amazon!
Martingale collars are generally regarded as one of the most secure-- They are recommended even for sighthounds that tend to have necks thicker than their heads. But they shouldn't be left on indoors because they're a greater strangulation hazard than normal collars.
They also make collars that are designed to just keep tags, that will break if too much pressure is applied. They're called tag collars or breakaway collars and can be left on a dog at all times. But they shouldn't be used to attach a leash.
Have you ever tried a martingale harness? We use them a lot in rescues as a lot of dogs tend to get out their collars or harnesses. This helps in addition to using the two leash method. You can find various sizes that could work for your dog on amazon if you haven’t tried. Wouldn’t want your pup to get out again. :(
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B009WADXCG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_t8whDbRP6V9ZE
What about a martingale collar? Those can slip on over the head while still being safe for walking (they tighten to regular collar size when there's pressure on the leash, so they don't slip off):
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0072DG764/ref=sr_ph?ie=UTF8&qid=1426947529&sr=1
http://www.amazon.com/PetSafe-Martingale-Collar-Quick-Buckle/dp/B00CZ7I120/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1426947529&sr=8-1
For these martingales, you can get it on/off your dog without ever messing with the quick release buckle (which is what I do with my standard poodle), but the quick release is also there in case of emergency.
Ruffwear is an EXCELLENT company, though. Great warranties on all their products, and their products really do last. Some of the sizing can be hit or miss for smaller breed dogs, so measure carefully.
These are my absolute FAVORITE leashes -- they work over the shoulder and in multiple lengths:
http://boldleaddesigns.com/shop/8-way-lead-6-ft-multi-functional-leash/
http://boldleaddesigns.com/shop/brahma-8-way-lead-6-ft-multi-functional-leash/
They also sell clip-on traffic leashes and can do a wide variety of custom buckles and other custom work.
This one looked interesting as well (haven't tried it personally):
http://boldleaddesigns.com/shop/quick-grab-plus-a-two-handled-hands-free-leather-dog-leash/
This is the one we use: https://www.amazon.com/EzyDog-Checkmate-Martingale-Style-Training-Correction/dp/B076TYJ31N/ref=sr_1_4?crid=325XZW1L3G7CA&keywords=ezydog%2Bmartingale%2Bcollar&qid=1567206085&s=gateway&sprefix=ezydog%2Bmar%2Caps%2C218&sr=8-4&th=1
I really like them!
I typically used a limited slip collar. Something like this: https://smile.amazon.com/Friends-Forever-Martingale-Reflective-Training/dp/B072FR7BYJ
This gives the same sound/sensation as a choke chain when you give a correction, but removes any chance/worry of them actually choking themselves if you have to tie them up or if they were to catch it on something.
If you need more control, a full choke chain or a pinch/prong collar can be used. Just don't leave it on them all time and make sure it is sized correctly.
We have never had much luck with not pulling - it’s just part of their nature if a squirrel is around! We try to allow as much time as possible off leash in safely fenced areas. We use the martingale collar linked below (size small fits a full grown B). It’s wider so at least distributes the stress over a wider area. We did use a front clasp harness for awhile but our breeder told us it was bad for their shoulders so we stopped. Biggest recommendation for leash training is consistency - every single walk is a practice opportunity. Use a string cheese or other high value treat and teach the pup when they’re not pulling and when they’re looking at you is when they will get rewarded. There are some good YouTube videos on this - it’s very important to reward at the right time.
If It Barks 1.5" Layered Ribbon... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01CR96GGI?ref=ppx_pop_mob_ap_share
So for the prong collar Herm Sprenger Neck Tech Stainless Steel Prong Dog Training Collar with Snap Hook Pet Pinch Collar No-Pull Collar for Dogs Made in Germany 19 inches https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07TNR2H8D/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_GNIRDbFT10FNC
And for dominant Ruffwear Cinch Collar for Dogs, Medium Sized Breeds Adjustable Fit, Reflective Trim, Size: Medium (36-51 cm/14-20 in), Kokanee Red, Chain Reaction Collar, 25701-604M https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B012A3T5ZK/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_i_0PIRDb9Y88VEZ.
👍
Once you get it fit right, you can get it on and off with just one of those plastic pinch connectors. I will note, I sometimes have issues with it even with normal hand strength. Especially if she's excited and wiggling to go out. Maybe a harness for your use and get a Martingale neck collar for use at Mom's? Once fit, those can simply be put on over the head.
Collar: use a martingale style collar, they are basically escape-proof and what we use on our shelter dogs since they can be flighty. Until he is trained, if you want extra security, put a harness on and have a second leash.
> Where can I get them?
Amazon has these. If you live in an Amazon-less place, I'm sure you can find others as well. You can also probably find a collar that's made with softer tips or caps already attached.
Like others, I would urge you to work on training your dog to walk without pulling so that you can ditch the prong collar fairly soon. You have a young dog of a biddable breed, so this is 100% doable. Also, just be clear with the babysitters that they need to remove the collar promptly after walking.
Good luck!
I wouldn't spend too much money on toys yet. You will want to see what his habits are before you really indulge. (E.g. we found out on day 1 that Duncan is a rope shredder when he went after our older dog's rope tug. He can't have rope toys, and I'm glad we didn't buy any new ones.)
Good luck!
It might just be hard to get the leash unhooked from the collar when the elevator is pulling it against gravity so hard. Throwing your weight on it is gonna help the initial tugh on your pooch but at some point you'd have to stop the thing.
I guess ideally you'd have some sort of collar you could just yank right over their head like one of these bad boys, but I'm sure not every dog's head is small enough to slide out without unclipping theirs :/
Hug-a-Dog are awesome, and hugely popular:
https://www.dachshunddelights.com/Hug-A-Dog-Harness_c_60.html
For hiking & daily use, we prefer a loose-fitting Martingale collar like this one.
http://www.amazon.com/Rogz-Reflective-Lumberjack-Obedience-Half-Check/dp/B002DX8QNU/ref=pd_sim_petsupplies_3?ie=UTF8&refRID=021MCM57DSD8D4A36QW1
Maybe this is what we need? Anyone have experience with choke collars like this?
I personally love a good cinch collar. Here's one like mine. Make sure you get one several inches longer than necessary, and never actually choke your dog with it. My friends with shephards use one of the pointy-er ones like this.
The technique is to walk at your own pace and as the dog pulls, they receive a negative feedback. When they stop pulling, the negative feedback is removed and the "staying close to you" is reinforced. You can help this by using a corrective-tone "don't pull" type command when they are pulling, and some praise when they walk well.
I have a one year old shepherd hound mutt on my hands. He's a totally different dog but I deal with these same things all the time (I imagine they're pretty common). This is what I do.
Best of luck!