I hope we get some replies. You might like the ones I have. I use my insoles for a week and then just throw them in the wash and dryer at the end of the week with the rest of the laundry. No more stink and ruined shoes! They are so close to perfect minus the thickness :(

I generally just go sockless, so I have terrycloth insoles in some of the shoes which I most commonly go sockless. They also come in white, but those are going to look pretty gross pretty quickly.

Beyond that, truly no-show socks are your friend. Ninjasox is the best option I've found.

My favorite shoe cleaning supplies

Angelus Water and Stain Repellant, Clear


Kiwi 209-000 Suede and Nubuck Care Kit


Shacke Suede & Nubuck 4-Way Leather Brush Cleaner



E6000 230010 Craft Adhesive, 3.7 Fluid Ounces

Saphir Renomat 100ml

B&E LIFE 5 Pairs Practical Plastic Adjustable Length Men Shoe Tree Stretcher Boot Holder Organizers 5 Pairs Black

You could get shoe trees for much cheaper, from Ikea for example but I just wanted to link something.

Angelus Easy Cleaner 8 Oz.


These brushes are the absolute best if you know better brushes let me know


Angelus Sole Bright 4 Oz Salon care 40 works too



IRIS USA, Inc. CNL-5 Storage Box, 5 Quart, Clear, 20 Pack


Dr. Scholl's WORK Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles (Men's 8-14) // All-Day Shock Absorption and Cushioning for Hard Surfaces (Packaging May Vary), 1 Count

EB Kicks,


If you know of any better products please let me know I don't believe I missed anything

This video is stupid helpful for white sneakers

Get Jordan 1 Glitter outta your shoes

http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B002SZFL7M/ref=mp_s_a_1_1?qid=1452190243&sr=8-1&pi=SY200_QL40&keywords=green+superfeet&dpPl=1&dpID=412jBU2hWnL&ref=plSrch&th=1&psc=1

Green ones do

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07HCXTDL6/ref=twister_B07QQDJ71J?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

​

These are my go to, they have a tongue and heel pad combo you can buy, these come in pairs (one comment said it was a single one per box, wrong). But they aren't made for right and left so you can use them singly and one box can be used on two right or two left shoes just fine.

I have used this to "fix" shoes. I have a low foot volume and sometimes shoes I really like fit me in length and in the toe box or are simply a size to big and these have been helpful. Quality materials and good adhesive.

​

Saphir makes an anatomical insole https://www.hangerproject.com/saphir-leather-anatomic-insole.html that people have recommended as well. I haven't tried these yet but Saphir is a goto with quality shoes care and accessories. These can help as well.

There are all kinds of quality leather insole options on amazon as well. You can cut them to fit as needed but don't go too big.

These terry cloth insoles work for me. Mostly.

I use Superfeet Yellows in my skates

I found the insoles retain the most stink. Rip out the original insoles and replace them with washable ones like these. Still sprinkle some baking soda in there once you have the original insoles out so it can get to the bottom surface of the shoe.

I wear these cotton shoe liners in some of my flats. Just puts a barrier between my foot and the sole. They definitely keep my flats looking good a little longer.

As a sweaty footed person myself, this is the best solution I have found. They are washable, don't slip, invisible in 99% of shoes, affordable, and I can wear them with flats or heels!

https://www.amazon.com/Pedag-Washable-Barefoot-US-36/dp/B001G0NSU2/ref=sr_1_3_a_it?ie=UTF8&qid=1540431131&sr=8-3&keywords=washable%2Bshoe%2Binserts&th=1

They come in white or black with either padding or a woven back depending on what your needs are. I also use Drisol on my feet to help control foot funk.

Knees, you're on your own, never figured that one out.

For feet though, these are amazing.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005AFHJY0

You could get some better insoles. Superfeet yellow are often recommended around here. They will eat up some volume in the boot and give you better arch support. I use them and really like them.

You might also consider getting some heavier running socks. They will be woven for arch support, moisture wicking and might work better than just doubling up. Plus, there'd only be one pair, so no rubbing issue. You can pick up irregular and/or overstock Smartwool socks at Sierra Trading Post for pretty cheap. Make sure you get a good coupon. They've always got some random coupon code active if you sign up for their emails (use a spam account, they send a new code like every other day). It changes a lot, so you might want to keep checking until you get a good one.

Last week I snagged the last of my size, 8.5 D, in the Eben boot, which was in the sale section. That sale section Rider offers is impressive and made what would be out of my reach attainable. I love that he offers it. It's good for guys who want well-made boots that look suitable for the office and don't want to pay Viberg prices or Alden prices (which are almost never eligible for coupons). And I love my Alden JCrew cordovan cap toe boots, don't get me wrong. But once I got those last summer, that was my huge splurge. No footwear for $400+ for a long time for me. To get the Eben at $200 is amazing when I consider the alternatives at that price.

Update: added comparison pics to Alden JCrew cordovan boot

Background:

About a year ago, I realized I had gotten tired of disposable footwear that broke down and started to hurt my joints (and I'm only 37!), that I couldn't re-sole after breaking them in, that were a waste of materials, etc. So I splurged for the Alden cordovan and resoled in Dainite by Aram of AH One Shoes as a super-durable high-quality choice. If I was only going to buy one pair of quality, versatile, long-lasting while staying good-looking boots, those were them. And then my wife and I agreed I can't be spending $600 (including the discounts!) on shoes every year. Ok, deal.

I had seen the Rider Boot Co Eben boots on Massdrop after getting my Alden boots and really thought they were fantastic looking. A high quality Alden Indy boot alternative that looks sleeker in my opinion and perhaps sturdier, too. I was extremely pleased to know about the durability and low maintenance of waxed Kudu (and that it was actual antelope, unlike Alden's "Kudu").

Fast forward to a couple of weeks ago when my low-quality brogue boot in rotation finally started to get a hole in the sole. I told my wife "I'm shopping for new boots and after having the Aldens I really don't want another disposable thing on my feet. I'm tired of having to go through it all again every year. They breakdown structurally before the sole gets a hole anyway. It just doesn't seem smart." She understood, but at the same time there was no way I was going to be able to spend $400 or $500 on Alden Indy boots. The alternative seemed to be JCrew house brand Pacer boots, made in China with plastic welts, soft soles, thin leather, synthetic footbed...and those cost like $150 with discounts. And although they're Goodyear welted, they still seemed like "how many resoles will I actually be able to get on these before they start falling apart, really." Just didn't seem like money well spent. It began to feel like I either somehow magically get a $400 boot, or I resign to get a $75 boot once again. There are Red Wings and Wolverines and Chippewas that can be had around $200, but the toe shape and actual workboot aesthetic limited their versatility. I needed to be able to wear my new boots to my office job. There are some Allen Edmonds that can be found for almost that cheap, but limited in the boot selection and often leather soled or 2nds quality. If I'd found new Daltons in Dainite for $200 I'd be all over them.

Initial Impressions:

I received the Eben boots yesterday and they're beautiful! I love the color in person, and the Kudu leather is so soft and distinctive without calling too much attention to itself. They appear to check the box for durable, good looking, low maintenance, and versatile. Also, I noticed that the soles are Dainite while the heels are made in Italy--I assume Sestriere. Interesting anyway. I've been extremely satisfied with the Dainite but had heard Sestriere is slightly softer. If true then I'm even happier to have this configuration rather than all Sestriere.

They feel extremely comfortable on the foot--soft and supple, but somehow sturdy, as well. I'll have to weigh them, but they feel lighter than the Alden JCrew cordovan boots. Those hold me upright and keep me grounded, while the Rider Eben is ready to spring into action.
Update: I weighed them and they're actually 3 oz heavier per boot than the Aldens! They don't feel that way on the foot.

Seeing them in person confirmed my impressions from the photos: they look like a sleek version of the Alden Indy boot. When I mentioned my Indy alternative description to Mr. Rider, he said that was the idea behind the boot--that a more tailored version of the Indy would be a good description.

Fit and Sizing:

The Massdrop description I found recommended TTS Brannock, and Mr. Rider confirmed that in an email I sent him just before ordering. He acknowledged that they would be longer in the toes than the Alden Barrie last boots.

My first impression was that they were extremely comfortable, but a half size too large. Just a feeling. However, I can say that I think the ball of my foot is lined up with the widest part of the boot, so perhaps I was just not accustomed to a longer toe that the Eben has. That said, there's more volume to the boot than I expected. The fit pic shows a comfortably snug lacing. It actually looks similar to my Alden Barrie last boots (which are size 8 D) but those feel more snug overall--granted they're broken in. It's hard to know when trying such a stiff sole as Dainite.

I took some more time later that night to try to achieve a good fit. With my standard not-too-thin socks that I wear with my Alden Barrie lasted boots, I snugged up the lacing more than in the album pic and got a better fit. The heel to ball length lines up and the elongated toe seemed somehow not as surprising to me. Still, they were slightly large-volume feeling on the top of my foot at the instep. I tried thicker socks, and this was just a degree too far--too tight at the top of the instep. Then, I tried an old removable Johnston and Murphy insole--very thin foam topped with a thin leather layer. Those combined with my standard socks did the trick! It was a Goldilocks moment. The insole insert is about 3mm thick.

Therefore, I'm considering either Tacco 613 or Pedag 102 insoles that appear to be identical flat, leather-topped, latex/charcoal foam inserts. I also am thinking about some Saphir flat, leather-topped, cork inserts, and I see an identical version called Kaps Pecari Cork Insoles available for cheaper on Amazon. The holes configurations and the leather texture appears to the the identical as the Saphir product. I've emailed Kaps and asked whether they are the supplier to Saphir. Any of these three are 2.5 mm to 3 mm thick and they're all cheap at $15 or less. My instinct is to go with the Kaps since it appears the same as Saphir I'd like to keep with a traditional cork foot-bed feel. However, maybe there's a good reason no one else offers that type, and there are numerous recommendations for the Tacco version here and on styleforum. Does anyone have any thought for or against the latex vs cork?
Note: Unless I'm mistaken from Mr. Rider's posts on styleforum, Rider Boot Co's Blake-Rapid construction has no corkbed between the insole and midsole.

Long term outlook and maintenance:

First this from CF Stead's page on Waxed Kudu:
"The Kudu is an antelope from Southern Africa, living wild in the bush. The antelope family have traditionally provided skins, which make unique leather. A striking combination of softness with strength.
We have used our ‘Janus’ tannage which was designed to maximise the natural mellowness of a calf skin and we combined this with a full wax impregnation, making a feature of the natural grain blemishes."

From what I have read and from what Mr. Rider has told me, there's not much to do to maintain Kudu. It's oiled and waxed for durability and has a rustic appearance so I expect normal wear will not change the appearance for the worse. I'm really curious to see how these will crease and age. The Kudu is thick but supple. It's a completely foreign material to me, so we'll see!

Additional observations:

1. There is a thin, black thread I noticed coming out of the moc toe stitching, crossing over to the other side, going back in, and coming out again. The end is shaped as if it was burned down--a tiny ball shape. I mentioned this to Mr. Rider to see if he has any thoughts on it. Update from Mr. Rider: It's not a structural stitch so nothing to worry about.
   
   
2. There appears to be a nick in the Kudu just above the welt on the inside of each boot. One appears more significant than the other. My only concern is to maintain the health of the leather and structural integrity. I've asked Mr. Rider if there is anything I should do. Update from Mr. Rider: He apologized, explained that there was probably a slip when they did the storm welt (done with a glass shard entirely by hand). He said there should be no worries and told me to keep him posted if anything comes of it.
   
   
3. It's extremely difficult to find a Kudu belt! I'm now in the market for something dark brown with red undertones, contrast stitching...considering keeping my eyes peeled for something in nubuck and then applying some conditioner. Open to suggestions.
   
   Thank you to Ron Rider for being so available, responsive, and patient with my questions and concerns! This has been an extremely satisfying process and I'm extremely impressed with the boots and the customer service.

I have these inserts for my flats, they're made of terry cloth--they're washable. If you don't want socks showing they're great in flats and you can wash them whenever you need to.

They're sort of like this: Inserts

Your rate and times are irrelevant for your first two weeks. After that it escalates on a weekly basis until you hit learning curve 5. AFAIK you’re supposed to be able to do 275 uph with takt time under 12 at the end of week three. Week 4 jumps up to 360 and takt time in 9s. Week 5 is when 400 and 8.5 takt or better matters for pickers in an AR FC. What really matter is your expected productivity percent. Basically that is the number you have to be over 90% of to avoid a write up after second week, and you need to have over 100 if you want to be assigned to secondary support roles.

As for soreness a few things can help. First and foremost get Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx Full Length Orthotic Shoe Insoles, Burgandy insoles (the red ones) for your shoes. Your feet and subsequently the rest of your body will thank you. Get a pair of SB SOX Compression Knee Brace (I use a pair old of socks with the toes cut out) and use a Solimo (Amazon cheap brand) knee brace because together they will save your knees wear and tear. Also get the Mueller wrap around elbow braces, which will help save you a lot of pain and suffering now and years down the road. Get a lifting belt/brace/back support and use it every other shift. Staying hydrated isn’t enough as a picker. Get yourself a 32 oz Insulated Kleen Kanteen. Fill it one quarter to one third with ice and use a combination of Cytomax drink powder at two scoops to one scoop of Bodybuilding.com Signature BCAA and bring three premixed containers of powder mix in the right ratios.Rubbermaid makes small plastic containers that I use, so you can refill the kanteen at each break. I keep a spare mix container in a mesh bag with a cliff bar or an apple and some small hard candies, which I attach via carabiner to my water-bottle going in and out that during work is attached to fence directly above water bottle holder. This drink will keep you hydrated, fueled, maintain electrolytes, and provide amino acids to prevent excessive muscular breakdown. Make sure you eat a tons of protein at each meal, including packing healthy lunches with lots of protein and possibly even include a protein shake/smoothies in an insulated container for lunchtime. Nutrition is key to fast recovery from the intense physical MMA prep workout they put us through.

Don’t be afraid to take restroom breaks right smack in the middle of your quarters, seriously. With regards to pod gaps, tote conveyor jams, and other issues out of a picker’s control it is helpful to keep a small notebook to log those things down and show it to your PA/AM/OpsM to have your time adjusted for those issues, which then adjusts your expected productivity percentage.

Ideally you want to stay right around 95% productivity by the time week 4 ends and you’re transfer eligible. If you do too good, then greedy af bonus hungry AMs will do everything possible to keep you as a picker. One woman I know has been a picker at my FC for two years. She hits 600. UPH with TAKT times that are in the 3/s-5/s range no problem, and she has been stuck picking and not given secondary roles because she is just that good at the job.

Have you tried insoles? Since you mentioned it's a hard floor maybe some gel or memory foam inserts would add a little cushion and relieve some of the pain? I really like the gel kind like these because my feet tend to get hot. The only thing I will caution is it depends on your shoe fit since you already ordered new ones you will want to make sure that they are still comfy with the added layer of the insoles (I find with some shoes the insoles make them too snug which also will not help with your foot pain....)
Sorry you are suffering, I hope you can find something that works for you :(

It depends on how much space you need to be taken up; I've used these a lot over the past few years to take up a little space in shoes that are either a little too big or have stretched.

Alternative option: these washable insoles. I have 3 or 4 pairs I rotate with my Valentino espadrilles and they keep my feet feelings clean and happy.

Although there are more knowledgeable folks around here, I've had to deal with some plantar fasciitis that flat insoles can flare up so I'll give this a rip. Not sure if you're looking for arch support so YMMV.

• 1)Most welted shoes don't have inserts that can be removed. There may be thin leather liner cemented onto the insole but that's it. The whole shoe is built around the insole like a car is built on the frame.
  
• 2. A resole doesn't change the insole. Maybe google shoe construction and learn for yourself how the welt is sewn onto the insole and upper (Goodyear welted, handwelted, stitchdown, etc) and then the outer sole is attached to the welt. A resole only replaces the outer sole and affiliated stitching. The insole could be replaced I suppose but that would require a complete rebuild on the original last and well... why would you? Might as well buy a new shoe.
     
• 3. Yes some brands have better support than others. In boots I have a pair of Whites which are famous for their Archease insoles. I love them. Nicks does too although I don't have any experience with them. Regarding shoes, Allen Edmunds have never caused me a problem. The best supporting shoe out if the box was actually from Buday a Hungarian maker.
     
• 4. I use Superfeet insoles in some of my flat insole shoes with generous lasts. Vibergs 2030 and Alden Barrie and Trubalance lasts are conducive for the low profile Superfeets. Alden also has their Modified last built to accept orthotics if u get a Prescription. I've never felt the need to see a podiatrist (yet) so These work well in more generous last and these work better in tighter shoes. Many of my shoes just won't accept an insert and I find these work well to avoid the plantar fasciitis.
     
     Good luck. I enjoy all my shoes despite the flat insoles. Good luck

15.5-17 homie. If you have a high arch go for green, otherwise go blue.

Superfeet Green Premium Insoles,Green,H: 15.5 - 17 US Mens https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002SZFL7M/ref=cm_sw_r_awd_LATJwbKYKFATR

I purchased these for a pair Rider boots in the 42 last that had too much volume. It worked perfectly. Also they're fairly inexpensive so it's worth a try.

I can’t recommend one insole over another. I don’t think I ever had a problem with the ones that come in any boots. I am currently rocking these and don’t have any problems so far at about 4 months of use: Dr Scholl’s

If you check the post you replied to, I added a link with some boot recommendations. My current pair are the Ariat Conquest GTX Square Hunting Boots. I’ve always favored 8” boots. If you know you don’t need waterproof boots, I’m more than likely going to buy the Thorogood Saw military boots next year. Super lights are niiiiice, this is the first pair I’ve seen that has a legal heel.

If they're used, they could very well be broken in but not to your specific foot. The previous owner could have had the skates baked and formed to their feet which would cause discomfort to another wearer.

I had an issue in that I never baked my skates (as well as bought the low end quality skate) and what I did to alleviate the foot pain was use skate insoles. Did me pretty well. Lasted me about 12-18 months, and I play upwards of 3 times a week.

This is the best answer, and I can vouch for Soles. http://www.amazon.com/Sole-Softec-Response-Custom-Footbed/dp/B001N0LEN8

Ideally you should be in what's called subtalar neutral when setting them, but if you just make sure your feet look mostly straight, you should be fine.

Comfort and dress shoes don't always mix, especially if you have had issues with other shoes in the past.

It's possible to get a more stylish shoe that will be comfortable, but it's going to take a little research or money or both.

It's hard to recommend a "comfortable" shoe, because it's very subjective. I sit in an office all day so I can wear any of my Allen Edmonds dress shoes and my feet are fine after work. I guess my commute involves about 30-40 mins of standing/walking each way, but that's not enough to give me any foot troubles.

I've read that Alden and John Lobb shoes are incredibly comfortable, even for dress shoes, but they are going to be in the $500-1000 range. Not sure you're interested in making that crazy of a purchase.

If you're on your feet the entire day and concerned with fashion and comfort, your best bet may be to buy a nice pair of dress shoes, and a walking insert sole to put into them. I've seen these recommended on MFA when similar advice has been asked. But I've never used them myself, so you'd have to look into that on your own.

You can try dress shoes specifically made to be comfortable like these offerings from Cole Hann. Again, I've never worn them, so I can't speak to their comfort specifically, but they are dress shoes made with athletic soles. That being said, Cole Hann usually isn't recommended around here as they fall into a price range of "too expensive" for mediocre quality dress shoes, but "too cheap" to actually be well made.

All of this being said, your main concern seems to be comfort. It sounds like you may be most happy continuing to wear the same shoes you have. They are cheap and get the job done. But you could look into a nicer pair to change into for after work drinks/dinner and/or weekend stuff. Maybe some casual beefroll penny loafers? Or some more formal loafers like these?

I've tried heel sticker/filler thing for my other shoes before but they always fell off. Never heard of a tongue pad.
Something like below?
https://www.amazon.com/Grips-Supra-Tongue-Large-XLarge/dp/B07HCXTDL6/ref=sxin_2_ac_d_rm?ac_md=0-0-dG9uZ3VlIHBhZA%3D%3D-ac_d_rm&keywords=tongue+pad&pd_rd_i=B07HCXTDL6&pd_rd_r=04e97116-2912-4312-a6e9-e973239f045e&pd_rd_w=pj1DN&pd_rd_wg=ZK38e&pf_rd_p=404c4843-2c96-4d0d-a5fe-2b0598693e61&pf_rd_r=8CD9PHDS77W2XZECK2JY&qid=1569415175

Wider shoes

Insoles (I use https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B000O5HE14/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1 )

Calf/hamstring stretches/foam roll

Roll your foot on top of a tennis ball

​

Buying wider shoes and using insoles helped me the most.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B001N0LEN8/ref=s9_simh_gw_d0_g309_i1?pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=mobile-1&pf_rd_r=1PAY9ZPCR1XYZMFAAMDR&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=1634797062&pf_rd_i=507846 their moldable shoe inserts

I bought one where you use scissors to cut it to the right size so can't really say hahaha. Here's the link if you're interested, they were a little cheaper when I bought them: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01M7VGCTI/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o05_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1#customerReviews

Insoles like these terry and sisal ones work well for me, and help keep your feet from sticking to the leather insoles. Bonus: washable.

I use these Dr Scholl's insoles - I found the surface lasts longer before grinding through. Better than Sof Sol Athlete.

So, if your insoles have holes under the balls/toes/heel - toss 'em & replace. Next, decent socks like Thorlo.

And the key - get a pumice stone and sand down your callouses EVERY DAY, in the shower. Problem solved.

The idea with insoles and socks is: you want the sock to slip on the insole - not your skin (layers) slipping (shearing) on the sock. This is what people are trying to achieve w/ double socks.

How big are you? If you are a bigger guy (>200 pounds) then I would recommend Dr. Scholl's Heavy Duty. If not, then ignore my recommendation and go with what everyone else is saying!

I think that’s company wide policy (at least in the US). But some stores are not as strict. I know that I definitely can tell the difference when I am either out of uniform or have accidentally worn the wrong shoes to work. (Working on the average 6 days a week for 3 years, I’ve accidentally put the wrong pair on 2 or 3 times)

Sketchers are definitely the best I’ve worn. These are the ones I usually buy. $37 a pair, free shipping if you are willing to wait... one time I ordered them on a Sunday night and they were sitting on my doorstep Tuesday morning. (With free shipping) other times, its the next week.

Skechers for Work Men's Felton Shoe, Black, 13 XW US https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00IWWSVKE/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_6fWiDbEWNN3M9


Edit: I’m also old and fat, so I also put dr shoes inserts in my shoes to help me handle the 12 hour days on my feet.

Dr. Scholl's HEAVY DUTY SUPPORT Pain Relief Orthotics (Men's 8-14) // Designed for Men over 200lbs https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01M8O5HLY/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_FmWiDbFTPDY6T

Or

Dr. Scholl's PLANTAR FASCIITIS Pain Relief Orthotics (Men's 8-13, Women's 6-10) // Relieve and Prevent Plantar Fasciitis Pain All Day https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01MPYEAI5/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_CpWiDb9CTBNV1

Worked good to combat the intense feet issue from all that standing.

I've heard good things about these.

Have you tried going a size bigger with your shoes? You could also try toe yoga https://youtu.be/wfYSEFwJMDA and doming https://youtu.be/Gm1YrjmAUP8. As far as orthotics go, my PT recommended these...

https://www.amazon.com/Superfeet-BLUE-Length-Insole-Blue/dp/B0011YEMDK/ref=sr_1_4?crid=F55XS3O7LNPT&keywords=superfeet+blue&qid=1568676184&s=gateway&sprefix=superfeet%2Caps%2C139&sr=8-4

I use these and like them:
https://www.amazon.com/Shock-Doctor-Insole-8-0-9-5-9-0-10-5/dp/B00BCGOYOO/ref=sr_1_6?ie=UTF8&qid=1501439184&sr=8-6&ppw=fresh&keywords=shock%2Bdoctor%2Binsoles&th=1&psc=1

Put a thin insole in only your right boot, or try a heel pad, try a tongue pad, try both, try all three, wear thicker socks?

Someone else on Reddit recommended these which you can get from Amazon. I ordered the size 11 for my 9E Grant Stones which were just slightly too roomy with medium weight socks. The insoles fit perfectly and make the boots comfortably snug and I just take them out if I'm wearing heavy wool socks.

For the clinic folks (male), loafers with nice insoles like these

This. I fence with some Sof Sole inserts in mine and it works pretty well. Just put them right on top of the existing insole. These are the ones I use: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002VEGMRS/ref=oh_aui_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I've got the same exact problem! I don't use custom orthotics, but I've got four pairs of Iron Rangers, and easily fit my inserts. I was initially given a pair by a podiatrist after I broke my foot, and it was a happy coincidence that they fit in my boots so well. I didn't even need to size up.

Nope, mine dropped right in. My foot is an 11.5, so I got the size F (11.5-13) Superfeet Black insoles for my size 11 boots (boot sizes run large, of course). Though, fair warning here, even though these are some of the slimmest insoles there are, they do still take up room and you may find the boots uncomfortably tight in the toe area. I have some other boots that these just won't work in, comfortably. Thankfully, I wear fairly thin socks, so it's not an issue in my Thursdays. I'm also going to pick up a pair of Superfeet Easyfit heel insoles, for my boots where there's not much extra room in the toe area.

For what it's worth... I swear by these insoles. I use then in my Red Wing Beckmans and other footwear.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000XY3XXE/

They seem like driving mocs, or simple loafers. Will something like this not work?http://www.amazon.com/dp/B017PIUNOW/ref=pd_lpo_sbs_dp_ss_3?pf_rd_p=1944687762&pf_rd_s=lpo-top-stripe-1&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_i=B00KCDV1V2&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=0X84104H4E8CYBY1HRJD

I've tried Superfeet Black and they're good for 1/2 size, maybe a touch more. They're very comfortable and useful if you have a low volume foot.

Insoles make a big difference. It's a lot easier to use an aftermarket insole rather than hunt around for a squash shoe that happens to come with a higher insole. I use Superfeet Blue, recommended from my doctor, which are designed for running and sports rather than day-to-day walking.

But be careful! It takes time to get used to the additional arch support when lunging for balls and changing direction quickly on the court. If you play too aggressively in higher insoles without practice, you could very easily roll an ankle or fall. Start with moderate arch support before working your way up to the high arch support models.

Thin leather insoles + thicker socks helps.

Pharmacist here, these are the exact shoes I have been using. Last pair held up about a year. I also use these

https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B000XY3XXE/ref=ppx_yo_mob_b_inactive_ship_o0_img?ie=UTF8&psc=1

when the memory foam insole wears down

I think the most popular insole option is Superfeet. I use them and they work great.

Are you new at this though? Like, really new? I ask because when I was first learning to skate, skating backwards absolutely killed my heels. I could wobble from the goal line to the blue line before I had to stop, it hurt too much.

I didn't really change anything skate-wise and this problem eventually solved itself (4 to 6 weeks, give or take...however long it took me to get significantly better), so my guess is that it was a combination of improved backwards skating posture and my feet getting used to the strain.

If you're not brand new, I guess ignore all of that.

Another option is terry cloth insoles (which are what I use because no-show socks inevitably slip off my ankles).

Powerstep Full Length Orthotic Shoe Insoles
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B005AFHJY0/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_YomTBbVMHEP95

Shoe itself was just from Payless. Whatever their non-slip brand is. Wore those shoes with those inserts for over a year and never had aching or soreness during a shift

I use these

Sof Sole Athlete Neutral Arch Comfort Insole, Men's Size 9-10.5 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002VEGMRS/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_yuAYBb51M2Z1Q

Everything can be found on Amazon, but the brand websites have a lot more detail if you are want it. But generally, I usually recommend the Powerstep Pinnacle or Protech, and either the Superfeet Blue or Black. Hope it helps!

I rock these in all my shoes. Love them for $25.

https://smile.amazon.com/Powerstep-Pinnacle-Length-Orthotic-Insoles/dp/B000O5HE14/ref=sr_1_fkmr0_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1495907894&sr=8-2-fkmr0&keywords=powerstep

Add these to any shoes and you will feel like you are walking on a cloud (assuming you are a man over 200lbs).

I'm a med student too, starting rotations in April/May! I searched the sub for this very reason.

I tried the dansko olive and olivia since they were the only danskos I thought looked good, but MAN did they kill my feet. I wore them for days trying to break them in, and no luck. The toe area was very tight (and I don't have big feet) and the heel was very uncomfortable.

I bought a pair of leather loafers by ecco on ebay, since I've had super comfy shoes by the same brand, and put Superfeet insoles in them. So far they're very comfy! I can't say enough good things about getting a good insole.

oh dude my feet are so flat.
I wear a 13 in most athletic shoes (Nike et Al) and a 12 in dress shoes. I'm able to wear a 12 in these and can fit these thin insoles in: https://www.amazon.com/Superfeet-Orthotic-Athletic-Footwear-Black/dp/B000XY3XXE/

sizing is similar to AE

Shoes like this one and this one are really good if you don't like heels but want some extra height. They don't feel so terrible on your feet. I also recommend you get some of these if you still find them uncomfortable.

Thanks for the contest!

Working in my birthday suit. Good luck with your job!

I have slightly different sized feet (which is very common). You have to size for the larger foot unless you want to go the MTO route. As was stated, AE will do this for the cost of the MTO fee ($125 IIRC).

Mine are about .25-.5 size difference. In most shoes, after they break in, they are fine. For others, I use a thin leather insole in just the left shoe. It feels strange for about a day and then I adjust.

For reference, I use these very thin Pedag insoles. I now have a nice collection of unused sz 11 right foot insoles if anyone has a larger left foot :)

I was juuust looking at insoles on* Amazon and a lot of people recommended these for stinky flats

I'm a fan of Naturalizer but you do have to sort through some rather dowdy styles to find nice ones.
When I worked in retail (i.e. standing all day), I bought myself a pair of inserts that I would put into whatever shoe I wore that day. That way even crappy flats with cardboard-like soles worked well.

I have terrible feet and can't be barefoot. The solution I found to this was to get inserts and use them in crocs slippers. I get my arch support, but they are still cozy. I dunno; maybe they would please you, too.

The thinnest ones (Black) I got were still a bit too thick to be used as a space filler. You might better off with something thing like:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001E53XH2/ref=wms_ohs_product

Gel inserts for my shoes would be awesome. I have trouble walking long distances (like through airports) because my feet ache so much! Those would help tons!

I lost one of my insoles at the rink a while back so I picked up these for a really good price and have been quite happy with them the past few months. I only did this because I skating on the bare rivets was starting to hurt, I would have not purchased anything if my stock ones were still intact.